The Tennessee Titans' recent decision to fire head coach Brian Callahan has left many scratching their heads, but one thing is crystal clear: Amy Strunk, the team's owner, has zero tolerance for embarrassment. And this season, the Titans have been anything but a source of pride. Let’s break down what led to this dramatic move and why it’s sparking so much debate.
The team’s performance has been, frankly, abysmal. Their rookie quarterback, Cam Ward—drafted No. 1 overall this year—has struggled to find his footing, completing just 55% of his passes with only three touchdowns and four interceptions in six games. The offense has been a shadow of what fans hoped for, and the results speak for themselves: a 1-5 start to the season, with a dismal 4-19 record under Callahan’s tenure. But here’s where it gets controversial: Was Callahan truly the problem, or is Strunk’s impulsive decision-making the root of the Titans’ woes?
The firing came just a day after a humiliating 20-10 loss to the Raiders in Las Vegas, a game attended by a large contingent of Strunk’s family. According to Sports Illustrated’s Albert Breer, this wasn’t just another loss—it was a personal blow to Strunk’s pride. ‘Amy doesn’t like being embarrassed,’ Breer noted on ‘Stillman and Co.’ He drew parallels to the 2023 firing of Mike Vrabel, suggesting Strunk’s decisions are often driven by her emotions and the last piece of advice she heard. Is this a pattern of reactive leadership, or is Strunk simply holding people accountable?
Vrabel’s case is particularly interesting. Despite leading the Titans to winning records in his first four seasons, including three playoff appearances and an AFC Championship game, he was let go after a 6-11 season in 2023. Now, he’s thriving as the Patriots’ head coach, with a 4-2 record behind QB Drake Maye. The irony? The Patriots are set to face the Titans this Sunday, adding another layer of tension to Callahan’s dismissal. ‘There was that feeling of embarrassment and the potential that it could get worse with Vrabel coming to town,’ Breer added. Could this have influenced Strunk’s timing? And if so, is that fair to the team?
Strunk’s absence from the press conference announcing Callahan’s firing only added to the speculation. President of football operations Chad Brinker claimed to be ‘representing her,’ but her no-show raised eyebrows. Meanwhile, the Titans narrowly avoided a winless start to the season thanks to a fortunate fumble by Cardinals running back Emari Demercado in Week 5. Without that stroke of luck, they’d be in even deeper trouble.
Callahan’s firing didn’t shock many around the NFL, according to Breer. ‘Amy’s now got a reputation of being an unpredictable owner capable of these sorts of things,’ he said. And this isn’t her first abrupt move—she fired GM Ran Carthon after just two years before hiring Mike Borgonzi, who’s in his first year with the team. Is Strunk’s unpredictability a strength or a liability? And how much longer will the Titans suffer the consequences of her decisions?
For fans looking to find some silver lining in this chaotic season, Underdog offers a chance to turn every NFL game into a win. With easy player picks, no season-long commitments, and real prizes every night, it’s a no-brainer. Use promo code NYPOST5 to get $50 in site credits when you play $5! (Must be 18+ and in a state where Underdog operates. Gambling concerns? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit www.ncpgambling.org.)
As the Titans move forward without Callahan, the big question remains: Can Amy Strunk’s emotional leadership style turn the franchise around, or is it time for a more stable approach? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—this is one debate that’s far from over.
